Sunday, October 16, 2005 8:59 AM
by
will
The Chinese Media and Abuse of Trust
ESWN
has translated an interesting article
from MediaChina.net on how people representing themselves as
journalists are extorting money from organizations and officials either
by offering to provide them with good press coverage or threatening
them with bad coverage. Apparently these fake journalists and news
organizations go as far as actually printing publications in some
circumstances:
According to the Liandu District public security bureau
director, these fake reporters pay close attention to their packaging
and exaggerate their positions. When they create their fake
magazines, they put photographs of major national leaders on the cover
and then print the words on the front page: "For the reading by senior
national leaders, National People's Congress delegates and National
Political Consultative Committee delegates." At the same time,
they falsely list certain Party and government leaders and other
well-known celebrities as their advisors or editorial committee
members. Furthermore, Wu rented an office from a certain Zhejiang
province government department in order to impress people with his
'connections.'
With these 'covers', Wu was successful. After a while, Wu must
have felt that he really was a reporter for a national
publication. When the police arrested him, he was in the process
of bullshitting two villagers who came to ask for his
"assistance." He told them that when he published the two
articles critical of Lishui City, both the Lishui City Party Secretary
and the Liandu District Party Secretary had come to plead with him but
he ignored them. When the police revealed their identity, Wu was
embarrassed and finally admitted: "This time, the bullshit went too
far!"
In recent years, there have been many cases of fake reporters working
at the grassroots level. Sometimes, even though the enterprises
and governments knew that these were fake reporters, they still let
them go. A grassroots level propaganda director said frankly that
fake reporters appear because the bad behavior in the media industry
provided fertile ground for them to grow. To some people,
reporters are people with connections -- they can leverage their job
positions, they are acquainted with the big shots, they can do "things"
that others cannot, and the media can be used to promote or destroy a
person's career. Many media workers do not approach work from the
viewpoint of producing the best report possible; instead, they maximize
their own interests through their special powers as media. This
tendency became the general belief about how media works. With
this impression, it is easy for the fake reporters to move in and
blackmail or deceive people.
It's interesting that the problem is blamed on insufficiently
disciplined legitimate media and abuse of power by actual journalists.
This suggests that the situation is somehow the fault of a media
industry that is not under sufficient control or regulation, rather
than the fault of, say, a pervasive culture of bureaucratic corruption.
Or a culture that emphasizes the value of relationships in advancing
agendas through the bureaucracy. Or a lack of other channels of
recourse for people with grievances.
This isn't meant to absolve those journalists who do abuse their
positions of trust. That can happen in any society, as people
everywhere see journalists as able to help them petition the powerful
or solve their problems. When I worked at a TV news assignment desk in
San Francisco, in the early nineties, we used to get regular calls from
desperate people who hoped that, somehow, a TV news organization could
help them to solve their personal problems. (I can't think of one
problem that we ever did help anyone solve.) The fact that people look
to journalists and news organizations as potential saviors creates
opportunities to betray trust.
There are perfectly reasonable ways of dealing with these situations.
I'm sure fraud is a crime in China, and can be punished as such, if the
government so chooses. As someone who is friends with several Chinese
reporters, I would be worried were the entire legitimate media to be
scapegoated for the behavior of a few con-artists, or even a few bent
journalists.
Worth a read.