Wednesday, October 19, 2005 12:04 AM
by
will
Wednesday PR Blog: Run For Your Lives! It's Bird Flu!
There is no force so unstoppable as an idea whose time has come. Even
if that idea is a panic-inducing over-reaction to a story that has been
in slow buildup for about eight years.
Bird flu has catapulted off of the science section and gone straight to
the front page of a news source near you, and thus escalated into a
full-on media hysteria. To read the coverage, especially in the wake of
recent outbreaks of the (avian variety of) bird flu in Europe in the
last few days, you could be forgiven for thinking that we are on the
verge of a civilization-ending event.
Honestly, if reality TV couldn't end civilization, this won't.
Actually, reality TV may pose a convincing argument for the conclusion
that civilization already has ended, in which case the bird flu is
moot, at best.
Anyway, I was particularly interested in this article from CNN, which comes with an appropriately apocalyptic headline:
Bird flu declared 'global threat'
Tuesday, October 18, 2005 Posted: 2150 GMT (0550 HKT)
LONDON, England -- European Union foreign ministers on Tuesday declared
the spread of bird flu from Asia into Europe a "global threat"
requiring international action.
The meeting issued a statement saying bird flu posed a serious, global
health threat if it shifted from birds to humans and one that required
"a coordinated international reaction."
However, European Health Commissioner Markos Kyprianou said that the
presence of bird flu in southeastern Europe did not increase the risk
of a pandemic.
Isn't this lovely? This same article points out that H5N1 avian flu
first emerged in Hong Kong in 1997. It has since appeared in China,
Vietnam, Indonesia, and much of the rest of Asia, where all of the
60-odd fatalities and most of the economic damage have been. But now
that it's
reaching Europe, it's a "global threat".
I would vouchsafe the following observation: bird flu became a global
threat when it emerged in China, which has forgotten more about keeping
birds, pigs and humans in close, unsanitary and flu-recombining proximity than Europe
has ever known. China also has an opaque government not fond of disclosing
the details of disease outbreaks, marginal healthcare facilities and,
lest it need be pointed out, one quarter of the global population.
Anyway, now that the
runs on Tamiflu
have begun, perhaps some perspective is in order. A good place to start
is
this lengthy but interesting article
on pandemic communications from
risk communications expert Peter Sandman, who suggests that a little
overreaction is a desirable and necessary part of the process. Sandman
writes:
When people are first confronting a risk they haven’t thought about
before, it is normal — and useful — to “over-react” for a while. Some
people become hyper-vigilant; some take precautions prematurely; some
obsess. Then a few people turn into fanatics, while most settle into
the New Normal, more attentive than previously to the new risk, but not
so obsessed anymore.
Officials are prone to misinterpret the public’s adjustment
reaction as panic or hysteria. Instead of helping people get through
it, they tend to try to tamp it down.
***
The least desirable risk communication response to the public’s
adjustment reaction to the pandemic flu threat is to insist that the
public is over-reacting. This is, if you will, an adjustment reaction
to the adjustment reaction, an official over-reaction to the public’s
over-reaction. (The technical term is “reactance.”) It will be
unfortunate if people cope with their new bird flu fears by buying less
chicken for a while. It will be more unfortunate if officials respond
to the decline in chicken sales, if that’s what happens, by staging
chicken-eating photo ops at which they ridicule the public for
panicking.
Predictably, of course, finger-lickin' good photo opps are
already being staged in a country near you (
here is one photo).
It's good to know that all of my own, personal strategies are being
validated. I am eating lots of chicken. I am also panicking. Not
necessarily at the same time, because that would result in chicken
grease getting everywhere, which is not nearly as much fun as chocolate
syrup getting everywhere.
Today brings news of another
outbreak in China.
Everyone will be pleased to hear that China claims the whole thing is
under control. That's good. China's outbreak is under control.
Romania's outbreak is under control. Russia's outbreak is under
control. Turkey's outbreak is under control. Macedonia's outbreak is
under control. Everybody's outbreak is, er, under control. Move along.
There's nothing to see here.
And that's the problem with birds, of course. The goddamn things fly,
and don't have common courtesy to carry national ID cards or register
properly at border crossings. Shoot the lot of them, I say. And then
deep fry them in the Colonel's secret mix of eleven herbs and spices
for good measure. It just doesn't take much intellectual rocketry to
see that the bird flu doesn't really care what we do. It's going to
march on until we vaccinate every domestic bird on the planet, and/or
it comes into some kind of equilibrium with the wild bird population.
And, if it evolves into a human-transmissible version, some kind of
equilibirum with the human population.
Remember this is still the Avian flu were talking about. It doesn't
actually infect people who aren't knee-deep in chicken-shit for twelve
hours a day. At least not yet. I may wade in bullshit, but so far there
has been no conclusive link between that and respiratory infections.
Although brain waistage can be expected.
Nevertheless, over the past two months, my wife and I have taken some
preparatory steps. Some may ridicule me for this, but I went through
the wierdness of SARS in Singapore, and I live in a
densely-populated city of fourteen million people with sanitation and
medical care that are mediocre at best. I never got sick in Singapore.
In Beijing I get some kind of stomach bug every eight weeks, and I have
a near-perpetual low-grade sinus infection. Last spring I had my worst
bout of (non-Avian) flu in about seven years. This is a good town for
diseases.
I'd like to point out that my preparations predate the current media
hysteria. I write this not to point out my prescience, but to
illustrate that I am quite capable of hysteria
without any prompting
from the media. Of course, as my med-student brother said, "If pandemic flu really does
break out, you're best bet is simply to stay in the house and wash your
hands a lot."
Sounds like good advice. Thank god for all those pirate DVDs and the Internet!