Friday, December 30, 2005 6:32 AM
by
will
Checkbook Diplomacy? How Dare They!
Imagethief was shocked (shocked!) to find out
through this AP article
on CNN.com that the scalliwags in the Chinese government are giving
money to the government of Suriname. Apparently, this is being done not
out of philanthropy, but out of
naked self-interest! Read on, if you dare:
China's 'dollar diplomacy': $2.5 million to Suriname
Thursday, December 29, 2005 Posted: 1924 GMT (0324 HKT)
PARAMARIBO, Suriname (AP) -- China's ambassador to Suriname has signed
an agreement worth $2.5 million, or 2.1 million euro, for civil
construction projects in this Suriname in South America.
"This shows that China is committed to help their friends in this part of the world," Ambassador Chen Jinghua said.
China and Taiwan have used dollar diplomacy for decades to win over
Caribbean nations, and Chen said Suriname is a strong ally in China's
claim on Taiwan, the so-called One China policy. Although democratic
Taiwan is self-governing, communist Beijing insists the island that
broke away amid civil war in 1949 still is part of China.
China also gave a $10 million (8.4 million euro) donation to Suriname's
foreign ministry for the construction of a new building, and regularly
donates money, training and equipment to Suriname's military. In
return, state-owned Chinese companies receive contracts using Chinese
laborers for various civil works in former Dutch colony.
Scurrilous. Well to prove to myself that the United States would never
be guilty of such self-interested "checkbook diplomacy", I hopped on
over to USAid's website, where I
crushed to discover
(click on the "historical dollar" link) that the United States has
forked over 450 billion dollars in loans, grants, repayments and
forgiveness since the end of World War II.
Eager to reassure myself that this can't have been self-motivated at all, I check the mission statement in USAid's
2004-2009 Strategic Plan (page 9) where I found the following:
Create a more secure, democratic, and prosperous world for the benefit of the American people and the international community.
For the benefit of the American people. It's right there in black and
white. US aid is motivated by a desire to confer benefit upon the
people of the United States, presumably by fostering American foreign
policy goals. Some of these are, no doubt, noble. Some probably less so.
So going back to the same page on which I found the total aid figures
(above), I checked the list of 2003 donations by country (the most
recent available) to see where our money was going. Among the savory
regimes cashing US checks:
- Egypt (just rigged an election) at 460 million.
- Iran (giving us the finger on their nuclear reactors) at 1.5 million.
- Yemen (kidnapping is the national sport) at 28 million.
- Sudan (massacring the residents of Darfur) at 186 million.
- Venezuela (anti-American president with oil) at 15.7 million.
- Pakistan (dictatorship) at 139 million (down from 770 million the year before).
- Uzbekistan (just massacred demonstrators) at 76 million.
- Suriname at 1.2 million (the Chinese have outbid us!).
- And, yes, China at 24.2 million.
Oh dear.
Imagethief is a supporter of well placed foreign aid, for a variety of
reasons. Fundamentally, we're rich and we can afford to share. And some
of the aid above goes through despicable regimes to get to truly needy
people who should not suffer for the depradations of their governments.
But let's get real here: no nation has a fatter checkbook for
lubricating diplomacy than the United States (unless you count aid as a
share of GDP, in which case
about twenty come in ahead of us).