Tuesday, January 24, 2006 10:05 PM
by
will
Another one bites the dust
No time to comment in any detail, but an article
worth a look from the
Washington Post's Philip Pan:
Leading Publication Shut Down In China
Government Move Part Of Wider Crackdown
By Philip P. Pan
BEIJING, Jan. 24 -- China's ruling Communist Party on Tuesday suspended
one of the premier publications in Chinese journalism, escalating a
campaign to rein in the state media, part of the government's toughest
crackdown on freedom of expression here in more than a decade.
The decision to shut down Freezing Point, a four-page weekly feature
section of the state-run China Youth Daily that often tested the
censors and challenged the party line, came less than a month after the
authorities replaced the top editors of another daring newspaper, the
Beijing News.
The China Youth Daily is the official newspaper of the Communist Youth
League, a power base for President Hu Jintao. Because any move to
punish it would almost certainly require his approval, the decision to
close Freezing Point was seen as further evidence of Hu's personal
support for a tightening of controls on the media that began two years
ago, about a year after Hu took office.
The article recalls
Freezing Point editor Li Datong's previous rail against one of the spookier episodes in China media management, a plan at parent publication
China Youth Daily to provide financial incentives for journalists who's stories reaped the approval of cadres:
Reached by telephone, Li said that it was inconvenient to discuss
what happened in detail but that he planned to write an essay to fight
the decision. He said propaganda officials issued a notice criticizing
him and the newspaper's editor in chief by name and ordering the
section closed until it is "rectified and fully recognizes and corrects
its mistakes."
Li, a party member and veteran journalist, stunned
the propaganda authorities last summer with a lengthy letter attacking
a plan to award bonuses to reporters at the newspaper who had won
praise from government officials while deducting pay from reporters
whose articles were criticized by officials. After the letter was
leaked, the newspaper scrapped the bonus plan.
Can you imagine a scheme by which American newspapers financially
rewarded journalists for writing stories that received the official
blessings of the administration? I should hope newspaper offices would
burn if that happened. (Not that American news organizations are immune
to ideology, of course. They're not. But it seems their motivations are
more prosaic, such as reaching a specific audience or satisfying an
owner's politics.) But here in China the regression proceeds apace, and
Party publications are certainly not immune. As generally heartened as
I am by the range and liveliness of Chinese media and the energy and
intelligence of the Chinese journalists I meet, every story like this
is depressing. More in the full article.
Update: Via
China Digital Times, the
New York Times coverage.