Friday, April 07, 2006 4:06 AM
by
will
Drink more liquor, by government decree
I love living in China because the country regularly produces news that
you couldn't make up even if you spent an evening smoking opium with
Lewis Carrol and a magical typewriter that recorded your zaniest
thoughts.
Everybody knows that governments love quotas and targets. With its
legacy of state-managed economy, China certainly has the pedigree for
this. Cue martial music: We will product X-million shoes this year, or
Y-million girlie magazines (strictly for the 光棍'儿, you understand), or
whatever. But never in my wildest dreams, even the ones that resulted
from drinking too much baijiu, did I imagine I would see the following
headline and story (here in its entirety):
Officials asked to drink 2-million-yuan alcohol
(Shanghai Daily)
Updated: 2006-04-07 09:09
Officials in a local government in Hubei Province were given a quota
this year to consume at least 2 million yuan (US$250,000) of alcohol
from a certain liquor company "as a support to its investment," a Hubei
newspaper said.
Hanzhou City government has issued an official notice to its 105
departments to use Xiaohutuxian liquors during official receptions,
citing a tipster.
For example, the target set for the Hanzhou government reception
department was 100,000 yuan, and the city's police station was 25,000
yuan.
The notice said that Guangzhou Pearl River Yunfeng Winery Co. Ltd., the
producer of Xiaohutuxian liquors, was a major investor in the city and
paid over 13 million yuan in taxes last year. But the company's local
sales weren't doing well, the notice said.
Departments fulfilling their targets will be rewarded with 10 percent of the quota, while ones that don't will be criticized.
The notice also said the decision aims to promote the local economy as well as attract more foreign investment.
An official of the local city government admitted that they indeed
issued the notice, but said departments that don't complete the quota
will only be criticized, not punished.
Actually, when I first saw the headline, which is gramatically
incorrect, I thought a bunch of officials was being asked to drink a
particularly expensive bottle of liquor. Perhaps it was a gift from a
liquor company grateful for the patronage, or it had been dug out of
the first sovereign emperor's tomb, or somesuch. I couldn't really
figure out how you could end up with a bottle worth that much though.
Perhaps something like a bottle of
Goldschlager, with more gold and less schlager (whatever that might be).
But, no, as you have read, the Hanzhou city government, in an attempt
to "support the investment" of the local hooch-works, is requiring its
officials to drink more of the struggling company's product. I've heard
of public pump priming, but never public liquor pump priming. Now,
apart from the obvious utter ridiculousness of this scheme and its
whiff of both corruption (assuming the departments will be spending
precious tax dollars on this swill or improperly leaning on their
employees to buy it) and alcoholism, I see a few problems.
First, I note that departments fulfilling their targets will be
rewarded with 10 percent of the quota. As if the thing you'll be dying
for after after choking down your allotment of Xiaohutuxian is...more
Xiaohutuxian! Hair of the dog that bit you, I guess. (And if their
sales are so bad that they need government support, it must be a dog
indeed.)
Second, assuming people purchase their required allotment but don't
necessarily drink it, the province runs the risk of being awash in a
huge surplus of Xiaohutuxian which, sooner or later, will cause local
demand to crash completely (assuming there is any demand to crash). So
they might really just be storing up trouble for the future. Sure, you
could have another quota the following year. But sooner or later all
that supply will catch up with the manifest lack of demand. I guess
they could burn the stuff for heat in winter, or pour it into flex-fuel
cars, or such.
Third, the announcement says that, "the decision aims to promote the
local economy as well as attract more foreign investment." Because
foreign investment always stampedes for the city so poorly managed that
it has to subsidize its liquor industry in such a way that all the
officials are practically guaranteed to be sloshed comatose. Yep,
that's a recipe for success if ever I saw one. Let's call Harvard
Business Review today and pitch the case study.
Finally, I think the quota for the police department needs to be
increased substantially. They'll need a break. After all, they're the
poor bastards who are going to have to clean up the mess. Well, them
and the hospital (whose quota is mysteriously not included in the
article).
Meanwhile, if you'll be attending any kind of government function or
banquet in Hubei in the near future, it's a safe bet you can expect to
be served nonstop shots of Xiaohutuxian. Hope you like it.
Note: Xiaohutuxian is
described thus:
With a long history of over 1000 years, it is produced along the
Chishui River of Guizhou province and enjoys a favorable reputation. It
is clear, pure and fragrant. Since one will feel intoxicated at the
sight of it even before enjoying, no wonder it is the superb one
extracted from the traditional Chinese wine culture.
Gosh. You'd think it'd sell gangbusters.