Thursday, August 31, 2006 9:42 PM
by
will
Public nuisance 1: Your placards are harassing me
An
interesting article on
Asia Times Online from Singaporean commentator (dare I say dissident?) Alex Au on the state of civil liberties there. Au has his eye firmly on the upcoming World Bank and IMF meetings, and reviews some recent attempts to demonstrate within the contraints of current Singapore law:
In a recent attempt to test the limits of this constitutional guarantee, four
people tried to mount a silent demonstration in front of the headquarters of the
government-run Central Provident Fund (CPF) in August 2005. They wore T-shirts
emblazoned with slogans calling on the CPF to be more transparent with
pensioners' funds while standing in complete silence. Soon thereafter, 40 or so
police officers in anti-riot gear confiscated their T-shirts and demanded that
they disperse because they were a "public nuisance".
Three of the four
silent protesters mounted a court challenge against the government for denying
them the freedom of assembly. However, Justice V K Rajah dismissed the suit,
ruling that the police could reasonably have deemed the words on the T-shirts
and placards as "insulting and/or abusive apropos those responsible" for
managing the CPF, a public institution, and that their being stationary in front
of the building represented harassment. "A persistent course of conduct for a
sustained period of time can constitute harassment," the judge ruled.
Another closely watched case testing the bounds of freedom of expression
and assembly is now being heard in Singapore's Subordinate Court system. Two
Singaporean citizens, Erh Boon Tiong and Ng Chye Huay, are being tried for
standing across the road from the Chinese Embassy on July 20 holding a banner
with the words, "Stop persecution of Falungong in China." The local media
reported police saying that the banner's message was likely "to cause harassment
to Chinese Embassy staff, visitors and passers-by".
Yep, a fragile and easily harassed lot those Chinese and Singaporean bureaucrats and pedestrians.