Monday, September 25, 2006 6:01 AM
by
will
More China PR trouble in the making for Yahoo?
I have only seen this one article (and only today, though it's a few days old), and its too early to say what, if any, repercussions it might have. But it raises an interesting question. As an American Internet company, how, exactly, would you defend yourself against a lawsuit on behalf of a jailed, Chinese journalist without looking swinish in the process? Mind you, this isn't about the legal defense (which I suspect won't be a big deal), but theAmerican PR implications of a legal defense:
Jailed Chinese journalist to sue Yahoo in US
Renewed focus on net freedom
Dan Nystedt
A Chinese journalist jailed in part due to email evidence provided by a Yahoo subsidiary plans to file a lawsuit in the US against the internet company within the next few months.
"We're also trying to line up other victims for a class-action. We've been in touch with a few others, but we haven't signed anyone up yet. It's a very sensitive issue because there could be reprisals against their families," said Albert Ho, a legislator in Hong Kong and lawyer in the case.
A Yahoo spokeswoman in Hong Kong could not be reached for comment.
A US civil suit against Yahoo on behalf of Shi Tao, a Chinese journalist convicted of "divulging state secrets" by Beijing in part due to an email Yahoo provided to Chinese authorities, is likely to be filed in either New York or California, Ho said. Tao's email, sent from a Yahoo account in April 2004 to a pro-China democracy website in New York, contained a Beijing order for officials to be on guard for unrest and dissident activity ahead of the 15th anniversary of the Tiananmen Square massacre.
Tao was sentenced to 10 years in prison.
The new lawsuit would come just months after Ho filed a complaint to Hong Kong authorities against Yahoo Holdings (Hong Kong) on behalf of Tao. It also comes at a time when international pressure is increasing on internet companies to handle the private data of their users more carefully, particularly with respect to human rights.
Might turn out to be nothing, but it has a definite radioactive glow about it. The Yahoo spokeswoman certainly kept her distance.