Saturday, May 19, 2007 4:54 AM
by
will
Observations on China journalism in Hessler interview
The Shanghai Journal blog has an interview (proxy link) with Peter Hessler, author of River Town and Oracle Bones and China journalist at large. If you like Hessler's writing, it's worth a read. Among other things, Hessler shares some interesting opinions about China reporting and the differences between newspaper and magazine journalism and books:
[I think] there is a tendency to politicize everything that is happening
in China. Analysts like to blame the Communist Party for everything,
when often there are deeper cultural and social reasons for the way
people act. Also, I think that the American press generally portrays
China as a darker place than it really is. There are complicated
reasons for this; it’s not a matter of prejudice or propaganda, but
rather a tradition of journalism. A good journalist is supposed to
expose injustice. But this approach can be a problem for a foreigner
working in China, because the American readers don’t have enough
context to put the injustice in perspective. They need to get a better
sense of what daily life is like.
***
Books give a writer much more freedom [than newspaper or magazine reporting]. It’s quite telling that in the
past ten years we’ve seen a real change in the type of China books that
are coming out, many of them by journalists, whereas most news coverage
seems to be stuck in the same ruts. The narrow structures of
traditional journalism have not been flexible enough to cope with
what’s happening in China. But the books have more freedom and they’ve
done a better job of reflecting this country.
The whole thing is worth a read.